Introduction: What is peer review?
Heather Douglas

In this talk, I will provide general definitions for what is peer review, including differentiations with public comment (which may not include “peers”) and peer consultations (which are generally less formal than peer “review”). In addition, I will describe differences among journal peer review, funding peer review, and regulatory peer review, in terms of both the goals of the review and the processes used in the review. These distinctions should help lay the groundwork for the day’s discussions.